How to Find Long-Tail Keywords That Actually Convert (2025 Guide)

You’re getting traffic. Lots of it. But your conversion rate is terrible.

Sound familiar? This is the trap most people fall into when targeting long-tail keywords. They chase search volume instead of search intent, bringing visitors who browse but never buy.

After analyzing hundreds of successful content campaigns, I’ve learned that the best long-tail keywords aren’t the ones with the most searches—they’re the ones that attract people ready to take action. In this guide, I’ll show you exactly how to find long-tail keywords that actually convert.

What are long-tail keywords (and why conversion matters)

Long-tail keywords are search phrases containing three or more words that are highly specific to what someone is searching for. Unlike broad “head” keywords, long-tail searches indicate clear intent.

Compare these two searches:

• “running shoes” (head keyword)
• “best trail running shoes for wide feet under $100” (long-tail keyword)

The first search could mean anything. The second? That person knows exactly what they want and they’re close to making a purchase decision.

Here’s the crucial difference most people miss: not all long-tail keywords convert equally well. Some bring curious browsers. Others bring ready buyers.

The conversion advantage of long-tail keywords

Studies consistently show that long-tail keywords convert 2.5x better than broad keywords. But that’s just an average. When you target the right long-tail keywords—the ones signaling commercial intent—conversion rates can be 5-10x higher.

Why? Because specificity equals intent. Someone searching for “running shoes” might be doing research, looking at fashion inspiration, or comparing brands. Someone searching for “Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 40 men’s size 11 free shipping” is ready to buy right now.

The goal isn’t just finding long-tail keywords. It’s finding long-tail keywords that indicate your ideal customer is ready to take action.

Understanding search intent: The key to high-converting keywords

Before you start researching keywords, you need to understand the four types of search intent. This determines whether someone will convert or bounce.

1. Informational intent

What it means: The searcher wants to learn something.

Examples:

• “what are long-tail keywords”
• “how does SEO work”
• “benefits of content marketing”

Conversion potential: Low. These searchers are in the research phase. They’re gathering information, not ready to buy.

When to target: Use these for top-of-funnel content that builds authority and captures email subscribers.

2. Navigational intent

What it means: The searcher wants to find a specific website or page.

Examples:

• “facebook login”
• “ahrefs pricing”
• “nike store near me”

Conversion potential: Medium to high, but only if you’re the brand they’re looking for.

When to target: Mostly relevant for brand terms and if you’re creating comparison content.

3. Commercial intent

What it means: The searcher is researching before making a purchase decision.

Examples:

• “best keyword research tools”
• “ahrefs vs semrush”
• “top running shoes for marathon training”

Conversion potential: High. These are your sweet spot. They’re past the learning phase and actively comparing options.

When to target: This is where most of your conversion-focused content should live. Create comparison guides, reviews, and “best of” lists.

4. Transactional intent

What it means: The searcher is ready to buy or take action right now.

Examples:

• “buy nike pegasus 40 size 11”
• “book SEO consultation”
• “download keyword research template”

Conversion potential: Extremely high. These people have their credit card out.

When to target: Always. These are direct revenue opportunities. Create product pages, booking pages, and download pages optimized for these terms.

Key insight: To find long-tail keywords that convert, focus primarily on commercial and transactional intent keywords. Informational keywords build traffic; commercial and transactional keywords build revenue.

The problem with most long-tail keyword research

Most guides on long-tail keywords teach you how to find them but not how to find the right ones. They show you tools that generate hundreds of keyword variations without considering which ones actually drive business results.

Common mistakes that kill conversions

Mistake 1: Chasing search volume

You find a long-tail keyword with 500 monthly searches and get excited. But when you rank for it, the traffic bounces immediately because those searchers aren’t your customers.

Search volume means nothing if the intent is wrong.

Mistake 2: Ignoring commercial signals

Keywords containing words like “buy,” “best,” “review,” “vs,” or “pricing” signal commercial intent. Missing these modifiers means missing revenue opportunities.

Mistake 3: Targeting too early in the funnel

“What is” keywords bring traffic but rarely conversions. Someone asking “what is project management software” isn’t ready to buy. Someone searching “best project management software for remote teams under $20/month” is.

Mistake 4: Not testing conversion rates

You assume a keyword will convert because it looks relevant. Then you rank #1, get traffic, and nothing happens. Without tracking conversion rates per keyword, you’re guessing.

How to find high-converting long-tail keywords (step-by-step)

Now let’s get into the practical methods. These strategies focus specifically on finding keywords that indicate commercial or transactional intent.

Method 1: Start with buyer keywords (commercial modifiers)

The fastest way to find converting long-tail keywords is adding commercial modifiers to your base keywords.

Start with your main keyword, then add these modifiers:

Comparison modifiers:

• best [product] for [use case]
• [product A] vs [product B]
• [product] alternatives
• [product] competitors
• top [product] for [specific need]

Purchase modifiers:

• buy [product]
• [product] price
• [product] cost
• [product] discount
• [product] coupon
• [product] free shipping
• [product] near me

Review modifiers:

• [product] review
• [product] reviews 2025
• is [product] worth it
• [product] pros and cons
• does [product] work

Problem-solving modifiers:

• how to [solve problem] with [product]
• [product] for [specific use case]
• [product] that [specific benefit]

Example in action:

Base keyword: “project management software”

High-converting variations:

• best project management software for small teams
• asana vs monday.com comparison
• affordable project management tools under $50
• project management software with time tracking
• buy project management software for remote teams

These variations attract people actively evaluating solutions—much more likely to convert than someone searching “project management software” alone.

Method 2: Mine your analytics for hidden gems

Your website analytics contains goldmines of high-converting keywords you’re already ranking for. Many people miss this.

In Google Analytics 4:

1. Go to Reports → Acquisition → Traffic acquisition
2. Add a secondary dimension for Session source / medium
3. Filter for “google / organic”
4. Sort by Conversions (not sessions)
5. Look for long-tail keywords driving actual conversions

In Google Search Console:

1. Go to Performance
2. Sort by Clicks
3. Look for keywords with decent clicks but lower than average position
4. Filter for keywords with 3+ words
5. Check which ones lead to conversions in Analytics

What to look for:

Keywords where you rank position 5-20 that are already converting. These are opportunities to improve rankings for proven converters.

Example: You rank #12 for “email marketing software for ecommerce stores” and it’s already driving 3 conversions per month. Optimize that page, build some links, and move to #3. Your conversions from that keyword could 5x.

Method 3: Steal converting keywords from competitors

Your competitors have already done the hard work of identifying which keywords convert. Here’s how to find them.

Using free methods:

1. Google your main product/service category
2. Look at the top 3-5 organic results
3. Visit each competitor’s site
4. Note the keywords they target in:
   • Page titles
   • H1 headings
   • Product category names
   • Blog post titles
5. Check their “Comparison” or “Alternatives” pages

Using Ahrefs (if you have access):

1. Enter competitor domain in Site Explorer
2. Go to Organic keywords report
3. Filter by:
   • Position: 1-10 (they’re ranking well)
   • Search volume: 50-1000 (realistic long-tail range)
   • Traffic: Sort descending (they’re getting actual clicks)
4. Export the list
5. Cross-reference with commercial intent modifiers

Pro tip: Look specifically at competitors’ comparison and review pages. These target high-intent keywords by design. If they have a page titled “Ahrefs vs Semrush,” they’re targeting that exact commercial comparison keyword.

Method 4: Use Google’s free features strategically

Google shows you exactly what converts—you just need to know where to look.

Google Autocomplete (with a twist):

Don’t just type your main keyword. Add commercial modifiers:

Type these into Google and note the suggestions:

• “best [your topic]”
• “how to choose [your topic]”
• “[your topic] vs”
• “buy [your topic]”
• “[your topic] for”

Example: Instead of typing “running shoes,” type “best running shoes for” and you’ll see:

• best running shoes for flat feet
• best running shoes for plantar fasciitis
• best running shoes for wide feet
• best running shoes for beginners

Each suggestion represents a specific customer need—and therefore better conversion potential.

People Also Ask (PAA) boxes:

Search your main keyword and expand the “People Also Ask” questions. Look specifically for:

• “What is the best…”
• “How do I choose…”
• “Which [product] should I…”

These question-based keywords often indicate commercial research phase.

Related Searches:

Scroll to the bottom of search results. Google shows 8-10 related searches based on real user behavior. These variations often include commercial modifiers you hadn’t considered.

Shopping results:

If Google shows shopping results for your keyword, that’s a strong signal people are ready to buy. Make note of:

• The exact product variations shown
• Price ranges in the listings
• Specific features highlighted

These details tell you what buyers care about—use them to create long-tail variations.

Method 5: Check Reddit and Quora for buying questions

People ask buying questions on forums that they might not type into Google. These goldmines of commercial intent often have low competition.

On Reddit:

1. Go to relevant subreddit (like r/entrepreneur for business tools)
2. Search: “[your topic] recommendations”
3. Look for threads with titles like:
   • “What’s the best [product] for…”
   • “Looking for [product] that…”
   • “Anyone tried [product]? Worth it?”
   • “[Product A] or [Product B]?”

On Quora:

1. Search your main topic
2. Filter by “Most viewed” questions
3. Look for questions containing:
   • “best”
   • “recommend”
   • “worth it”
   • “should I buy”

Example from real Reddit thread:

Thread title: “What’s the best password manager for a small business that’s actually easy to use?”

This exact phrase is a high-converting long-tail keyword. Someone asking this is ready to buy, they just need validation. If you rank for it, your conversion rate will be high because you’re matching their exact need.

Method 6: Use Google Keyword Planner for commercial terms

While most people use Keyword Planner to find search volumes, you can use it specifically to find commercial variations.

How to find converting keywords in Keyword Planner:

1. Go to Discover new keywords
2. Enter your main keyword
3. Add commercial modifiers to the “Expand your search” field:
   • best
   • buy
   • vs
   • review
   • price
4. Look at the “Top of page bid (high range)” column

Key insight: Higher CPC (cost-per-click) usually indicates commercial intent. If advertisers pay $15 per click, that keyword probably converts well. They wouldn’t pay that much otherwise.

Filter for:

• CPC above $5 (or whatever is high for your industry)
• Competition: Low to Medium
• Average monthly searches: 50-500

This sweet spot gives you commercial keywords that are still achievable to rank for.

Method 7: Analyze keywords from your PPC campaigns

If you run Google Ads, your search query reports contain proven converting keywords.

In Google Ads:

1. Go to Campaigns
2. Click Keywords → Search terms
3. Add columns for:
   • Conversions
   • Conversion rate
   • Cost per conversion
4. Sort by Conversions (descending)
5. Export keywords with conversion rate above your target

What you’re looking for:

Long-tail search terms that people actually typed (not just keywords you bid on) that led to conversions. These are the exact phrases converting visitors use.

Example insight:

You bid on “keyword research tools” broadly. Your search query report shows:

• “free keyword research tools for beginners” → 12 conversions
• “keyword research tools better than google planner” → 8 conversions

These specific phrases convert. Now create organic content targeting these exact terms.

How to evaluate if a long-tail keyword will convert

You’ve found potential keywords. Now you need to validate them before investing time creating content.

The SCORE framework for conversion potential

Use this five-point checklist:

S - Search Intent (most important)

• Does the keyword include commercial modifiers?
• Does it indicate someone ready to buy/subscribe/book?
• Does Google show ads for this term? (signals commercial value)

C - Competition Level

• Can you realistically rank in the top 5?
• Are the current top results from major brands or other blogs?
• Do the top results have thin content you can beat?

O - Opportunity for Differentiation

• Can you offer something unique the top results don’t?
• Is there a specific angle no one’s covering?
• Can you add more value (better data, clearer format, actionable steps)?

R - Relevance to Your Product/Service

• Does this keyword attract your ideal customer?
• Can you naturally mention your product/service in the content?
• Would someone searching this benefit from what you offer?

E - Estimated Traffic Value

• What’s the potential monthly traffic if you rank #1?
• What’s your typical conversion rate for similar content?
• Does the math work? (Traffic × conversion rate × customer value)

If a keyword scores high on all five factors, prioritize it. If it scores low on Search Intent or Relevance, skip it even if search volume is high.

Quick validation: The SERP test

Before committing to a keyword, Google it and ask:

1. Are there ads? If yes → commercial value confirmed. Companies bid on keywords that convert.

2. What type of content ranks?

• Product pages? → Transactional intent
• Comparison articles? → Commercial intent
• How-to guides? → Informational intent

Match your content type to what’s already ranking.

3. Can you compete?

• Look at the domain authority of ranking sites
• Check content quality and depth
• Evaluate freshness (is everything from 2019? opportunity!)

4. Do the titles indicate solving a problem? If top results say “best,” “vs,” “review,” or “how to choose,” this keyword has commercial intent.

Creating content that converts for long-tail keywords

Finding high-converting keywords is half the battle. The other half is creating content that actually converts the traffic.

Content formats that convert best

Different long-tail keywords need different content formats:

For “best [product]” keywords:

• Create comparison articles with clear recommendations
• Include pros, cons, and specific use cases
• Add your product/service as an option (transparently)
• Use tables for easy comparison
• Include actual prices

For “[product A] vs [product B]” keywords:

• Head-to-head comparison
• Side-by-side feature tables
• Clear winner for specific use cases
• Include your product if relevant as a third option

For “how to [problem]” keywords:

• Step-by-step guide
• Mention tools that help (including yours)
• Include a CTA to your relevant product/service at the end

For “buy [product]” keywords:

• Product page or landing page (not blog post)
• Clear specifications, pricing, and features
• Social proof (reviews, testimonials)
• Strong CTA above the fold

Conversion optimization basics

1. Match intent immediately

Your H1 should echo the search query. If someone searches “best email marketing software for small business,” your H1 should be similar: “7 Best Email Marketing Tools for Small Businesses (2025)”

2. Add conversion elements:

Even in blog content, include:

• Relevant CTAs at natural breaks
• Product mentions where they solve problems discussed
• Email capture for content upgrades
• Booking links for consultations

3. Remove conversion friction:

• Make buttons stand out
• Use action-oriented copy (“Get Started” not “Learn More”)
• Reduce form fields (email only if possible)
• Add trust signals (testimonials, badges, stats)

4. Track everything:

Set up conversion tracking for:

• Button clicks
• Form submissions
• Email signups
• Time on page
• Scroll depth

Test which keywords drive conversions, not just traffic.

Advanced strategies for finding converting keywords

Once you’ve mastered the basics, these advanced tactics can uncover even better opportunities.

The “problem + solution” formula

People search problems, not products. Find high-intent problems and map them to your solutions.

Framework:

[Problem/Pain Point] + [Qualifier] + [Desired Outcome]

Examples:

• “slow website loading time” + “ecommerce” + “solutions”
• “email list” + “not growing” + “tips”
• “project management” + “team not using” + “how to fix”

These problem-focused keywords often have lower competition but higher conversion rates because you’re solving a specific pain.

The “near me” + “online” opportunity

Local + digital is an underused goldmine.

Examples:

• “SEO consultant near me” → also target “hire SEO consultant online”
• “yoga classes near me” → also target “online yoga classes for beginners”

You can rank for local terms even if you’re not local by offering online alternatives.

The comparison cluster strategy

Don’t just target one comparison keyword. Create a cluster:

Main comparison: “Ahrefs vs Semrush”

Supporting cluster:

• “Ahrefs vs Semrush for beginners”
• “Ahrefs vs Semrush pricing comparison”
• “Ahrefs vs Semrush for backlink analysis”
• “Which is better Ahrefs or Semrush 2025”

Each variation attracts slightly different searchers, all with high commercial intent.

Mining Amazon and e-commerce reviews

If you sell products or recommend products, Amazon reviews contain buying language.

What to do:

1. Find top products in your category on Amazon
2. Read the 3-star and 4-star reviews (not 5-star)
3. Note the specific problems people mention
4. Note the features they wish existed
5. Turn these into long-tail keywords

Example:

3-star review: “Good shoes but wish they had better arch support for flat feet”

Keyword opportunity: “running shoes with arch support for flat feet”

This is exactly what a segment of buyers wants. Target it.

Common mistakes to avoid

Even with the right process, these mistakes can sabotage your results:

1. Creating content for keywords you can’t monetize

High conversion rates don’t matter if you can’t actually make money from the traffic.

Bad example: You sell project management software but target “free project management templates.” High traffic, zero sales.

Good example: Target “best project management software for agencies under $50/month.” Lower traffic, but they’re looking for paid solutions.

2. Ignoring search volume entirely

While search volume isn’t everything, zero searches means zero traffic. Find the balance.

Target keywords with:

• Minimum 20-50 monthly searches (for new sites)
• Minimum 100-300 monthly searches (for established sites)

Below that, the ROI on content creation usually doesn’t justify the effort.

3. Not updating for seasonality

Some converting keywords are seasonal. “Black Friday deals” converts great in November, poorly in March.

Check Google Trends before investing in content. If searches spike at certain times, time your publication accordingly.

4. Stopping at one keyword per page

A single page can rank for dozens of related long-tail keywords if structured properly.

Instead of:

• One article for “best running shoes”

Do this:

• One comprehensive article targeting:
  • best running shoes for beginners
  • best running shoes for flat feet
  • best running shoes under $100
  • best running shoes for marathon training

Use H2s and H3s to target each variation within one piece.

Tools for finding converting long-tail keywords

While I’ve focused on manual methods, these tools can speed up the process:

Free tools:

• Google Keyword Planner - CPC data indicates commercial value
• Google Search Console - Shows converting keywords you already rank for
• AnswerThePublic - Question-based keywords often have commercial intent
• Reddit search - Real buying questions
• Google Trends - Verify demand isn’t declining

Paid tools (worth it if budget allows):

• Ahrefs - Best for competitor keyword analysis and filtering by intent
• Semrush - Strong for keyword difficulty and commercial intent filtering
• Keywords Everywhere - Chrome extension showing search volume everywhere
• AlsoAsked - Uncovers question-based keywords from PAA boxes

Pro tip: Start with free tools. Only invest in paid tools once you’re consistently creating content and need to scale research.

Real examples: Long-tail keywords that convert

Theory is great. Here are real examples showing how this works:

Example 1: SaaS company

Low-converting keyword: “project management” (5,000 searches/month)

• Informational intent
• Conversion rate: 0.3%
• Signups per month: 45

High-converting keyword: “best project management tool for remote teams under 20 people” (120 searches/month)

• Commercial intent
• Conversion rate: 8%
• Signups per month: 77

Lower traffic, more signups.

Example 2: E-commerce site

Low-converting keyword: “men’s running shoes” (22,000 searches/month)

• Mixed intent
• Conversion rate: 0.8%
• Sales: 176

High-converting keyword: “Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 40 men’s size 11 on sale” (80 searches/month)

• Transactional intent
• Conversion rate: 31%
• Sales: 25

While this specific keyword brings fewer sales, create 20 variations like this and you’re at 500 sales from long-tail alone—all with much higher ROI because PPC costs are lower for specific terms.

Example 3: Service business

Low-converting keyword: “SEO services” (9,000 searches/month)

• Vague intent
• Conversion rate: 1.2%
• Consultations booked: 108

High-converting keyword: “technical SEO audit for SaaS company” (70 searches/month)

• Specific commercial intent
• Conversion rate: 18%
• Consultations booked: 13

The second keyword attracts exactly the right customer—SaaS companies needing technical audits. It converts at 15x the rate.

Measuring success: Are your keywords actually converting?

You’ve created content. Now track whether it’s working.

Key metrics to monitor

1. Conversion rate per keyword

In Google Analytics 4:

• Go to Explorations
• Create custom report tracking:
  • Dimension: Landing page
  • Metric: Conversions
  • Secondary dimension: Source / Medium (for organic)

This shows which pages (and their target keywords) actually drive conversions.

2. Assisted conversions

Not all converting keywords drive direct conversions. Some start the journey.

In GA4, check Advertising → Attribution to see the full path to conversion. Long-tail informational keywords often appear early in the journey, commercial keywords appear later.

3. Time to conversion

Some keywords convert fast (transactional), others take weeks (commercial research).

Track:

• Average days from first visit to conversion
• Which keywords lead to quick conversions (prioritize these)

4. Revenue per keyword

If you have e-commerce tracking set up:

• Conversion rate is nice
• Revenue per keyword is what actually matters

A keyword with 100 visitors and $5,000 revenue beats one with 1,000 visitors and $2,000 revenue.

When to optimize vs when to abandon

Optimize when:

• Keyword ranks but conversion rate is below site average
• You’re getting impressions but few clicks (improve title/meta)
• You rank #5-15 (opportunity to climb with minor improvements)

Abandon when:

• After 6 months, keyword brings no conversions despite decent traffic
• Search intent clearly doesn’t match your offering
• Competition is impossible (every result is Forbes, NYT, etc.)

Focus energy on keywords showing promise, not salvaging lost causes.

Action plan: Your next 30 days

Here’s your step-by-step plan to find and rank for converting long-tail keywords:

Week 1: Research

• Day 1-2: Review Google Analytics for converting keywords you already rank for
• Day 3-4: Use Google Autocomplete + PAA to find commercial variations
• Day 5-7: Analyze 3 competitors’ top commercial keywords

Week 2: Validation

• Day 8-10: Use the SCORE framework to evaluate your keyword list
• Day 11-12: Check SERP for each top keyword (ads, competition, content type)
• Day 13-14: Prioritize top 10 keywords by conversion potential

Week 3: Content Creation

• Day 15-17: Create your first piece targeting top commercial keyword
• Day 18-19: Optimize on-page elements (title, meta, H1, H2s)
• Day 20-21: Add conversion elements (CTAs, forms, product mentions)

Week 4: Launch and Promote

• Day 22: Publish content
• Day 23-24: Build 3-5 initial backlinks
• Day 25-26: Share on social media and relevant communities
• Day 27-30: Set up tracking and monitor initial performance

Month 2 and beyond:

• Create content for 2-3 converting keywords per week
• Monitor conversion rates and optimize underperformers
• Double down on keywords that convert well

Frequently asked questions

What’s a good conversion rate for long-tail keywords?

It varies by industry, but aim for:

• Informational keywords: 1-3%
• Commercial keywords: 5-15%
• Transactional keywords: 15-30%+

If you’re below these ranges, either the keyword intent doesn’t match your offering or your content/conversion elements need optimization.

How long does it take to rank for long-tail keywords?

Typically 3-6 months for new sites, 1-3 months for established sites with existing authority. Low-competition long-tail keywords can rank faster—sometimes within weeks.

Should I target low-volume keywords (under 50 searches/month)?

For established sites with resources, yes. These often have the highest conversion rates and lowest competition. For new sites trying to build initial traction, focus on 100-500 monthly search volume first.

Can one piece of content target multiple long-tail keywords?

Absolutely. A comprehensive guide can rank for dozens of related long-tail variations. Use H2s and H3s to target specific variations within the main piece.

How many long-tail keywords should I target per month?

Start with 5-10 high-quality pieces per month if you’re just beginning. As you build systems, scale to 20-40 keywords per month. Quality over quantity always wins.

What if I’m in a boring industry with low-volume keywords?

Perfect for long-tail strategy. Boring industries often have less competition and higher commercial intent. Someone searching “industrial valve supplier Cleveland Ohio ANSI certified” knows exactly what they want.

How do I find long-tail keywords if I’m brand new to a topic?

Start with competitor research. See what established players rank for, then filter for commercial modifiers. Also leverage Reddit and Quora to understand what questions real customers ask.

Conclusion: Traffic means nothing without conversions

Most SEO advice focuses on getting traffic. This guide focused on getting the right traffic—the kind that actually converts into customers.

Remember the core principle: Search volume is vanity. Conversion rate is sanity. Revenue is reality.

Finding long-tail keywords that convert isn’t about fancy tools or complicated processes. It’s about understanding buyer intent and matching your content to the specific problems your ideal customers are trying to solve.

Start with the methods in this guide. Pick five commercial-intent long-tail keywords this week. Create one piece of content targeting the best one. Track conversions.

Then repeat. Every week, target more converting keywords. Over time, you’ll build a portfolio of content that doesn’t just bring visitors—it brings customers.

The best long-tail keyword you’ll ever find isn’t the one with the most searches. It’s the one that brings someone ready to buy exactly what you offer.

Now go find yours.

---

Ready to improve your keyword strategy? Use our free keyword research tools to find opportunities, or book an SEO consultation to get expert help identifying your highest-converting keywords.